I finally decided to try PBK again, and I'm so glad I did. They were having a sale, so with tax and shipping we only spent right at $200. I did not order a bumper as we won't be using one, but I did get the crib skirt, quilt, matching pillow sham for pillow for the rocker, and I went with a white with pink polka dots crib sheet.
It came in, and it was exactly what I wanted. It's called the Ruffle Collection.